Community Boss

## LM2 - Data Hub SYS13 - Formula Hint 2

Hi Team,

In the Data Hub in module SYS13 Account SKU Filter you setup a Boolean line item to determine whether there is data in DAT03

My formula to be used would of been:  TIMESUM(DAT03) > 0  or TIMESUM(DAT03) <> 0

The 2nd Anaplan formula hint is below:

This is confusing as when/why would you use a Number (1/2) to determine the TRUE/FALSE nature rather than use the native Boolean logic of 0 & 1?

Thanks

Mark

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
Master Anaplanner/Community Boss

Hi @MarkTurkenburg

I feel there is a misunderstanding here. What are your concerns? I can see 3 concerns here: (correct me if I'm wrong)

1. There is a 1 / 2 in the THEN ELSE parts of the IF statement?

2. A TRUE FALSE should have been used instead

3. Native Boolean Logic  of 0 &1

Let me start with the number 3. 0 and 1 and are not native Boolean logic. TRUE/FALSE are.

In the 3 parts of an IF THEN ELSE statement, the only part that should resolve to TRUE or FALSE is the part after the IF. However, the THEN and ELSE sections could resolve to ANYTHING -including Boolean.

The Example provided literally translates to .... IF the condition of x not equal 1000 is met THEN resolve to or enter the value of 1, and if the condition is not met enter the value 2.
an IF statement could be used in a line item of any format, in the example provided that format is NUMBER so whatever comes after the THEN and ELSE should resolve to NUMBER.

Einas
"Give a Man a Fish, and You Feed Him for a Day. Teach a Man To Fish, and You Feed Him for a Lifetime"

Dear community members
Consider posting your question as a new topic and not in the thread of another topic/question. This help other community members to easily find the answer they looking for and doesn't cause the original thread to be so cluttered that we can't find what we are looking for
8 REPLIES 8
Master Anaplanner/Community Boss

Hi @MarkTurkenburg

I feel there is a misunderstanding here. What are your concerns? I can see 3 concerns here: (correct me if I'm wrong)

1. There is a 1 / 2 in the THEN ELSE parts of the IF statement?

2. A TRUE FALSE should have been used instead

3. Native Boolean Logic  of 0 &1

Let me start with the number 3. 0 and 1 and are not native Boolean logic. TRUE/FALSE are.

In the 3 parts of an IF THEN ELSE statement, the only part that should resolve to TRUE or FALSE is the part after the IF. However, the THEN and ELSE sections could resolve to ANYTHING -including Boolean.

The Example provided literally translates to .... IF the condition of x not equal 1000 is met THEN resolve to or enter the value of 1, and if the condition is not met enter the value 2.
an IF statement could be used in a line item of any format, in the example provided that format is NUMBER so whatever comes after the THEN and ELSE should resolve to NUMBER.

Einas
"Give a Man a Fish, and You Feed Him for a Day. Teach a Man To Fish, and You Feed Him for a Lifetime"

Dear community members
Consider posting your question as a new topic and not in the thread of another topic/question. This help other community members to easily find the answer they looking for and doesn't cause the original thread to be so cluttered that we can't find what we are looking for
Community Boss

Thanks @einas.ibrahim

I think I wrote the post in haste as I was confused as to my formula was not approved as correct in the LM2 but then looking about at the 2nd post the example provided is not actually for the question & hence they were not using 1/2 as the answer

New Contributor

Hi, and that formula to be used would be TIMESUM('DAT03 Historic Volumes'.Volumes) <> 0

New Contributor

This is the formula I thought should work but when I try it I get an error saying "Invalid formula for 'SYS13 Account SKU Filter'.Has Data?: Automatic sum of 'DAT03 Historic Volumes'.Volumes over SKU Flat hierarchy is not possible as SKU Flat does not have a built-in top level"

My DAT03 Historic Volumes module uses the SKU Flat list as instructed in the course. How can I solve this error?

Master Anaplanner/Community Boss

Hello @aaturnbu

Can you please share the instruction to use P3 SKU Flat in the historical volume module? I don't believe using the flat with this module is correct, and that's the reason for the error you are getting.

Einas
"Give a Man a Fish, and You Feed Him for a Day. Teach a Man To Fish, and You Feed Him for a Lifetime"

Dear community members
Consider posting your question as a new topic and not in the thread of another topic/question. This help other community members to easily find the answer they looking for and doesn't cause the original thread to be so cluttered that we can't find what we are looking for
New Contributor

Here's the screenshot from the course:

It clearly says to use the flat list.

I found the problem though, I was not using the flat list in SYS13, I had selected the P3 SKU hierarchical list by mistake. It works now that both modules are using the flat list.

Contributor

not enough 😞 if then else is missing for boolean format
IF TIMESUM('DAT03 Historic Volumes'.Volumes) <> 0 THEN TRUE ELSE FALSE

Occasional Contributor

This is what I had, on the exam I got the question wrong.